THE CLEARER EDIT / PATTERNS
Why Dating Apps Feel Exhausting — and Why More Choice Isn’t Helping
Dating apps gave us more access to potential partners than ever before. But more choice does not always make choosing — or connecting — easier.
Most of us know that feeling well: you’re tired of relationships, even though you haven’t actually been in one for a long time. You’re scrolling through Tinder or Bumble or, fine, let’s say Hinge at midnight in the darkness of your bedroom, and after endless swiping all the faces in the photos start blending into one repeating face. You have to get up for work at 7 a.m., but when, if not at night, does loneliness become more effective than caffeine? So we keep swiping desperately. People need people, and that’s normal. What isn’t normal is how difficult it has become to find one.
When more choice makes choosing harder
I’m not going to burden you with history or stories about how everything used to be better, because if we found ourselves at any point in any era, the number of things we would want to edit would never get smaller. Our century is wonderful if only because we no longer generally share the fear, voiced by some physicians in early modern Europe, that bathing could let disease into the body. In our century, most of us at least smell good, and that is something worth celebrating.
But what about everything else? Some people won’t agree with me here, but sometimes I think that when you don’t have much choice, choosing might actually be easier. I’m not talking about forced marriages, but imagine your options were basically Tom, a family friend, or Baron Ferguson, who had travelled from the neighbouring province to ask for your hand. The decision would at least have fewer moving parts. Maybe that’s why we binge-watch Bridgerton. Their problems are somehow both more complicated and simpler at the same time.
We, on the other hand, live in an age of global choice. Not all of us, obviously, but at least those who use dating apps and happily ignore age limits and distance settings — like me, for example, hello — can potentially meet Jared from Mumbai just as easily as Karl from next door. By opening the world of dating apps, we potentially open the world of endless choice too. But that world comes with its own traps.
The saying “you’re judged by your clothes” is almost more applicable to dating apps than to real life. In real life, we know that someone wearing a T-shirt full of holes might actually be wearing Balenciaga. On dating apps, there is almost too much context. A profile gives you a rough idea of a potential partner’s income, job and interests — or at least the impression of them. People who have been on these apps for years become so used to looking at profiles that they can sort someone into “yes” or “no” within seconds. We learn to categorise people very quickly.
Why dating app conversations are so easy to abandon
The first impression created by a profile is a tool for generating choice. A good first impression opens more doors. But even then, the game simply moves to the second level without becoming any easier. Especially if the point of the game is finding the one. Although you would be surprised how many people are on dating apps simply because they want to be chosen. No judgement. That has its place too.
Dating apps require almost no effort to approach someone, which is probably one reason why so little real communication comes out of them. I mean, to start some basic conversation or maintain light, non-committal contact, you no longer have to involve two families and negotiate a dowry, as happened in some historical marriage arrangements. You certainly don’t have to kidnap your potential partner — bride abduction has been documented in parts of the Caucasus, but it was never a universal courtship custom. What a relief.
When starting a conversation costs us almost nothing, abandoning it costs almost nothing too. Although who would argue that it is much easier to take that lightly when this is not your only match?
The problem with always waiting for someone better
Research has explored links between attachment style and dating-app behaviour, although findings on avoidant attachment are mixed. That is not a basis for claiming that avoidant people stay on apps longer or become disproportionately represented there.
Whatever someone’s attachment style, people who have plenty of choice on dating apps can suffer not from a lack of options, but from the illusion of them. You would think that if you have lots of matches and lots of conversations, finding a partner should be easier. But in reality, a little worm of doubt starts crawling around in many people’s heads: what if someone more attractive or better appears tomorrow? Sometimes, when I watch reels about all the things that gave men and women the ick on first dates, it starts to feel like the safest thing to do is not even breathe. In the end, we love things and use people. It would be better the other way around.
I have quite a few male friends in their early forties who have never been married and want to start a family. All of them are on dating apps, and all of them can get the ick from absolutely anything, down to the color of a cardigan not matching the color of someone’s shoes. I gave one of them some free advice: delete every dating app at once. The feeling that someone better might appear tomorrow and the desire to build a family don’t work particularly well together, because you never actually get to the depth required for real intimacy.
People are not a list of specifications
A person is not a product with a list of specifications where “better” always means “better for you.” What is actually better for us does not always look better on paper. If you passionately love throwing your things everywhere, you are probably better off not moving in with an obsessive neat freak. On a list of desirable partner qualities, “loves cleanliness” might sound better, but you won’t care much about that when you’re being driven to the morgue because one day your beloved finally killed you after asking you to pick up your socks for the thousandth time.
Looking for love has somehow become unfashionable. What is fashionable now is self-sufficiency, self-realization, and, generally speaking, everything beginning with self-. I don’t believe people are supposed to be alone, but I also don’t believe that any relationship is better than no relationship. And still, we keep opening dating apps.
We are often afraid to write that we are looking for something serious or that we want a family because we worry about sounding too intense or boring. In reality, nobody cares about our lives quite as much as we do. And just like with a technical brief, if you don’t specify the details and requirements, the final product may look nothing like what you wanted. You can, of course, sign off on it and accept it anyway, but we don’t do that in business, so why would we do it when it comes to our one and only life?
Remember why you downloaded the app
Dating apps should simply be used to find whatever it is you are looking for—whether that is love for life or love for one night, it doesn’t really matter. But definitely not just to sit on dating apps forever.
Hinge’s slogan says it was designed to be deleted. I think the most important thing in all this madness is not to miss that moment. The chances that Baron Ferguson, whom you have never met, will suddenly arrive to ask for your hand, or that a prince or princess will climb through your window because the only places anyone can find you are at home or at work, are incredibly small, if not exactly zero. So it is important to give yourself a chance to find your people using the methods we actually have now. But please, look for people.
Don’t forget why you downloaded all of this in the first place.
If dating feels difficult but you’re not sure where the friction is happening, start with the free Dating Landscape Assessment.
Sources / Further Reading
This is a personal essay. The research below explores choice and app use; it does not establish why any particular person is single or diagnose anyone’s attachment style.
- Pronk & Denissen (2020). A Rejection Mind-Set: Choice Overload in Online Dating. Social Psychological and Personality Science. Three studies of partner selection and rejection.
- Thomas, Binder & Matthes (2022). The agony of partner choice. Computers in Human Behavior. Survey and experimental research on perceived partner availability and choice overload.
- Thomas, Binder, Stevic & Matthes (2023). 99 + matches but a spark ain’t one. Telematics and Informatics. A survey of 16–25-year-old app users links excessive swiping with comparison, fear of being single and choice overload; it does not establish causation or represent every age group.
- Topino, Griffiths & Gori (2026). Attachment Styles and Dating App Use: A PRISMA-Based Systematic Literature Review. European Psychologist. Findings on avoidant attachment are mixed.
- Historical context: Renaissance Skin: “Porous skin”; The Metropolitan Museum of Art on Renaissance marriage chests and dowries; UNFPA, Child Marriage in Georgia. These describe particular periods and communities, not universal customs.
Related Clearer reading: Dating burnout in men and Why successful men struggle with dating.